X’s decline in engagement and its skill to drive visitors is the subject du jour, with a number of days of dangerous PR for the Elon Musk-owned social community.
Over the weekend, X’s head of product, Nikita Bier, and knowledge analyst Nate Silver, beforehand of FiveThirtyEight, feuded over whether or not or not X was nonetheless able to sending visitors to publishers. This was adopted by a report from NiemanLab on Wednesday, which steered that including hyperlinks to X posts is dangerous for engagement.
On Thursday, the distinguished digital rights group and nonprofit EFF (Digital Frontier Basis) announced it, too, was leaving X after seeing lowering returns from its posts.
In a blog post, EFF’s social media supervisor, Kenyatta Thomas, mentioned that leaving X after nearly 20 years on the platform wasn’t “a call we made frivolously,” however defined that the mathematics now not works out in its favor.
In 2018, EFF’s posts to Twitter noticed between 50 and 100 million impressions per 30 days, she mentioned. By 2024, its 2,500 posts on the social platform generated round 2 million impressions per 30 days. Final yr, EFF’s 1,500 posts earned roughly 13 million impressions for your entire yr.
“To place it bluntly, an X submit at this time receives lower than 3% of the views a single tweet delivered seven years in the past,” Thomas wrote.
The group will proceed to submit on Fb, Instagram, TikTok, YouTube, and elsewhere on the open social internet, noting that its presence on a platform just isn’t an endorsement of those providers.
Techcrunch occasion
San Francisco, CA
|
October 13-15, 2026
“We keep as a result of the individuals on these platforms deserve entry to data, too. We keep as a result of a few of our most-read posts are those criticizing the very platform we’re posting on,” Thomas mentioned. “X is now not the place the battle is occurring.” (Ouch!)
EFF is considered one of many organizations to ditch X, following different high-profile exits which have included varied information publishers like NPR, PBS, The Guardian, Le Monde, and others, in addition to many academics, celebs, local governments, and more.
The information organizations might have had varied causes to go away X, however visitors may have saved them round. For some, like NPR and PBS, the departure was a response to Musk’s resolution to falsely label them as “state-affiliated media,” a title typically reserved for mouthpieces of governments that lack editorial independence — similar to Russia and China-based propaganda networks. For others, like Le Monde, it was a response to Musk’s shut ties with Trump.
However it’s simpler to take a stand when you could have little to nothing to lose.
Immediately, any supply of visitors is extremely invaluable, as publishers cope with shifts in on-line client habits. AI utilization is ramping up, killing visitors to publishers on the identical time that information websites are seeing declining referrals from engines like google and Fb. That’s left many newsrooms to fold beneath the monetary strain or conduct layoffs.
In Bier’s debate with Silver, he accused newsrooms of utilizing X incorrect.
Bier stressed that information retailers like The New York Occasions ought to be posting in a approach to encourage dialog on X’s platform, not simply utilizing X as a information feed to publish a easy headline and a hyperlink. Silver, nevertheless, identified that even when he did the work to generate on-platform dialogue, it didn’t present a lot of a carry by way of visitors to his web site.
“The conversion to off-site visitors may be very middling,” Silver wrote on X. “Perhaps 2-3% of the readership for a Silver Bulletin article as an alternative of ~1%.” By comparability, he famous that Twitter used to ship FiveThirtyEight round 15% of its visitors.
Even a few of Silver’s detractors appeared to agree along with his evaluation of X, which he published in a newsletter. Specifically, X is now dominated by conservative influencers, and plenty of high accounts by way of engagement are low high quality. (As an example, Silver identified that the account “Catturd,” a right-wing influencer identified for spreading conspiracy theories, sees extra engagement than The New York Occasions.)
Musk, in fact, dismissed this evaluation, calling Silver’s knowledge “bullshit” in a reply.
NiemanLab’s own analysis involving 18 giant publishers’ most up-to-date 200 posts usually supported Silver’s claims. It discovered that newsrooms publishing hyperlinks alongside X posts have been seeing poor engagement — together with on future posts.
That doesn’t essentially imply X is downranking their posts — the corporate claims it stopped doing that — it may simply imply that X just isn’t as occurring because it was earlier than.
